In Geopolitics Today: Wednesday, September 20th
Russian-Brokered Ceasefire Holds in Nagorno-Karabakh, Escalating Cyber Espionage Accusations Between China and the US, and other stories.
Iraq Disarms Kurdish Opposition Groups Near Border
Iraq has disarmed Iranian Kurdish opposition groups near their shared border, fulfilling a deal with Iran to remove the perceived threat. Baghdad relocated the groups, including the Kurdistan Freedom Party and Democratic Party of Iranian Kurdistan, away from the frontier. Tehran had threatened military action if Iraq failed to act by September 19th.
Iraq's move aims to ease Iranian concerns that Kurdish groups are stoking unrest in Iran's Kurdistan province during protests over Mahsa Amini's death. Baghdad faces competing pressures from Iran and its own Kurdish population. While seeking to avoid an Iranian incursion, Iraq risks backlash from Kurds opposing crackdowns on fellow Kurds. Much depends on Iran's response, as it may still see Kurdish groups as fair game for retaliation. With protests raging in Iran, tensions remain high. But Iraq's actions reflect its vulnerabilities, as foreign rivalries play out on its soil. Blocking cross-border attacks could help prevent a regional crisis. But lasting stability requires addressing the root grievances fuelling turmoil in both countries.
Read more about this story here.
Russian-Brokered Ceasefire Holds in Nagorno-Karabakh
A Russian-brokered ceasefire took effect in the disputed Nagorno-Karabakh region after two days of fighting between ethnic Armenian forces and Azerbaijan. Authorities in the Armenian-populated enclave agreed to the truce proposed by Russian peacekeepers. It envisions the disarmament and withdrawal of local Armenian troops, allowing Azerbaijan to take control of territory it seeks to annex. Intense clashes had erupted despite international efforts to bring peace between the rivals.
The swift ceasefire prevented a full-scale war from erupting, but stability remains fragile. Russia retains leverage as peace arbiter, but lasting peace will require good faith from both Baku and Yerevan. Disputes over territory, refugees and resources still run deep. With nationalism high, concessions won't come easy. But this flare-up showed the perils of escalation, as civilians perished. Diplomacy should now focus on confidence-building and pragmatic steps forward to gradually normalize relations between these estranged neighbours.
Read more about this story here.
Escalating Cyber Espionage Accusations Between China and the US
China has accused the US of conducting cyberattacks to steal data from companies like Huawei since 2009. This follows a Chinese report alleging the NSA infiltrated Huawei's servers. The accusations reflect escalating espionage claims between the two powers amid growing strategic tensions. China now alleges longstanding US hacking operations, while boosting counter-espionage laws. The spat spotlights technology as a key arena of rivalry.
As US-China competition intensifies, spying accusations fly in both directions. While details are murky, the optics inflame nationalist sentiments. With technology and data security critical for economic strength and military edge, suspicions of spying fan distrust. The claims and counterclaims make meaningful trust-building difficult. Meanwhile, the digital domain grows more contested. As each side boosts cyber capabilities, risks grow of misperceptions and unintended escalation. Technical and diplomatic initiatives are needed to mitigate these dangers.
Read more about this story here.
India and the US Forge Closer Energy Ties at G20 Summit
At the recent G20 summit, India and the US pledged to strengthen energy ties, eyeing closer collaboration on renewables and nuclear power. This builds on initiatives like the US-India Strategic Clean Energy Partnership launched last year to advance clean tech trade and innovation. With both aiming to counter China's dominance and support India's development, Prime Minister Modi and President Biden are prioritizing strategic alignment in energy.
While deepening US-India energy links, discrepancies persist in their stances toward Russia. India treads a fine line, keeping energy security and costs foremost while avoiding jeopardizing relations with Washington. Meanwhile, clean energy cooperation may further integrate two massive economies. But progress requires navigating geopolitical crosscurrents. India resists abandonment of Russian energy deals, even as it sees alignment with the US and West as indispensable for its rise. Managing these competing impulses will challenge Indian diplomacy as global alliances flux.
Read more about this story here.
Diplomatic Row Between India and Canada
A diplomatic row has erupted between India and Canada after Ottawa accused Indian agents of killing a Sikh separatist leader in Canada in June. Canada expelled an Indian diplomat and warned of terrorism threats, prompting India to reject the "unsubstantiated" claims and eject a Canadian envoy. The crisis stems from Canada's refusal to clamp down on Sikh separatists that India deems terrorists.
With nationalist politicians in both countries playing to domestic audiences, further retaliation appears likely. Near-term risks include disruptive protests by separatist groups in Canada and suspended bilateral initiatives. The spat spotlights how diaspora groups can fuel tensions between their home and host countries. For Modi's Hindu nationalist government, cracking down on separatism is central to its platform. Meanwhile, Trudeau depends on Sikh support in Canada. Neither wants to appear soft amid nationalist pressures. While economic fallout may be limited, the fraying ties bode ill for collaboration in the Indo-Pacific. Deft diplomacy could still contain the crisis. But domestic politics may trump level heads, risking an escalatory dynamic neither capital desires.
Read more about this story here.
CIA Director William Burns' Insights into US-Russia Relations
A new compilation from the Russia Matters program shares insights on Russia from William Burns, the Director of the CIA. Drawing on statements made throughout his career, it provides a window into the thinking of a key figure shaping current US policy. As a former ambassador to Russia and deputy Secretary of State, Burns offers deep knowledge of this bilateral relationship.
The quotes highlight consistent themes in his approach — advocating pragmatism and caution regarding Russia amid more hawkish views. With US-Russia tensions escalating, Burns provides an influential moderate voice cautioning against rash policies. His stress on clear-eyed diplomacy reflects lessons from past ups and downs with Russia. While underscoring areas of rivalry, he argues for avoiding extremes and retaining channels of communication. As policymakers weigh responses to Russia's actions, Burns' perspectives offer considerations often lost in partisan debates. With his unique background, he exemplifies the value of experience and expertise in navigating turbulent great power relations.